Monday Night Predictions: Browns vs. Steelers NFL Picks, Preview & NFL Odds

These teams had a head-to-head record last season that favored the Browns, especially when Baker Mayfield was under center. Over their last 5 H2H clashes, the Browns have won 3 times. As for NFL Week 2 Predictions, the Browns are expected to maintain their winning form, particularly with their strong defensive lineup.

How to Watch Browns vs. Steelers

• Date: Monday, Sept. 18, 2023
• Kick Off: 8:15 p.m. ET
• Location: Acrisure Stadium — Pittsburgh, PA
• Where to Watch: ABC

After a commanding 31-17 win over the Cincinnati Bengals in Week 1, the Cleveland Browns are carrying significant momentum into this AFC North clash. Deshaun Watson, Cleveland's quarterback, has thrown for 154 yards, completing 55% of his passes. On the receiving end, Jarvis Landry and Odell Beckham Jr. have collectively tallied 112 yards. Defensively, the Browns are conceding an average of 17 points and 321 yards each game. Myles Garrett is leading the defensive efforts with 3 sacks. Meanwhile, the team's ground game is averaging 133 yards per matchup, with Nick Chubb contributing 87 yards and a touchdown. The Browns are favorites with NFL Week 2 odds of -2 on the spread.

Key Players Missing:

• Amari Cooper (groin)

⭐  CLICK HERE to bet on the Steelers vs. Browns game! ⭐ 

On the other side, Kenny Pickett had a mixed performance in the Steelers' 24-17 loss to the San Francisco 49ers, throwing for 232 yards but also two interceptions. Receivers JuJu Smith-Schuster and Chase Claypool have together chalked up 128 yards. On the defensive front, Pittsburgh is giving up an average of 24 points and 389 yards per game. T.J. Watt is at the forefront with 2 sacks. The Steelers' rushing attack averages 76 yards per game, led by Najee Harris's 42 yards on 15 carries. The Steelers are underdogs with a +115 moneyline and will be keen to avoid a second straight loss.

Key Players Missing

• Cam Heyward (injury)
• Dionte Johnson (out)

The Browns have been inconsistent in recent games (including pre-season), with wins against the Bengals and Jets but losses against the Chiefs and Washington Commanders. The Steelers, on the other hand, have won 3 of their last 4 games, including a win against the Browns earlier this year. Given the recent form and head-to-head matchups, Monday Night Football picks lean slightly in favor of the Steelers. Lets take a closer look at our Browns vs. Steelers Predictions and NFL Picks: 

⭐ NFL Pick 1: Steelers +2 ATS (-120) at BetMGM

The Pittsburgh Steelers have shown resilience in their recent games, bouncing back from a 30-7 loss against the San Francisco 49ers with wins over the Atlanta Falcons and Buffalo Bills. Historically, the Steelers have been strong against the spread (ATS) when coming off a loss, covering in 7 of their last 10 such situations. Their defense, led by T.J. Watt, has been a cornerstone, ranking in the top 10 for fewest points allowed per game. Given that the Browns have struggled against top-tier defenses, taking the Steelers at +2 ATS at BetMGM is a well-backed choice.

⭐ NFL Pick 2: Over 38.5 total points (-110) at Caesars

When it comes to offensive capabilities, both the Browns and Steelers have been lighting up the scoreboard. The Browns put up 24 points against a solid Cincinnati Bengals defense, while the Steelers managed 27 against the Buffalo Bills. Moreover, the Over has hit in 4 of the last 5 head-to-head matchups between these two teams. With key offensive players like Baker Mayfield for the Browns and Najee Harris for the Steelers in good form, the Over 38.5 total points at Caesars is a bet that aligns well with recent trends and player performances.

⭐ NFL Player Prop: Nick Chubb anytime TD scorer (+100) at FanDuel

Nick Chubb has been a touchdown machine for the Browns, scoring in 3 of their last 4 games. He's particularly effective in the red zone, where the Browns have a 75% conversion rate for touchdowns. The Steelers' defense, while strong overall, has shown some vulnerability against the run, allowing an average of 4.3 yards per carry. Given that the Steelers will likely focus on stopping the Browns' potent passing attack, this opens up opportunities for Chubb. Taking him as an anytime TD scorer at FanDuel at +100 offers excellent value.